What’s the Difference Between Select, Choice, and Prime Steak? Let’s Break It Down
When I’m choosing cuts of beef for an event, I don’t just grab whatever’s on the shelf. There’s a system behind the best steaks you’ve ever tasted—and it all starts with USDA grading.
If you’ve ever seen “USDA Prime,” “Choice,” or “Select” on a menu or at the butcher counter and wondered what the heck that means, let me give you the inside scoop. These grades are based on two things: the age of the animal and the amount of marbling (those little white streaks of fat that melt into juicy flavor).
🥩 USDA Prime
This is the gold standard. Only about 2–3% of all beef gets a Prime rating. It’s well-marbled, tender, and super flavorful. You’ll find this at high-end steakhouses and in our premium catering packages when the occasion calls for a showstopper. Think ribeyes, tenderloins, and NY strips that melt in your mouth. I love using Prime cuts when I really want to impress.
🥩 USDA Choice
Choice is the middle tier and what I use most often for events. It still has good marbling, but not quite as much as Prime. It’s juicy, tender, and perfect for grilling or roasting. Choice gives you a great balance of quality and value, which is why I serve it confidently for weddings, luncheons, and corporate dinners.
🥩 USDA Select
Select is leaner and has the least marbling of the three. It’s not as juicy, but with the right marinade or slow-cooking method, it can still shine. I’ll use Select for more budget-friendly menus or if a client wants a leaner protein option. It’s also great sliced thin in fajitas or steak salads.
At Bread Crumbs Catering, we pick the right grade for the job—whether that’s buttery Prime for a VIP dinner or tender Choice for a corporate barbecue. Knowing the difference means we can serve you steak that fits your event and your budget.
Ready to taste the difference?
👉 Check out our menu
📸 See what’s sizzling on Instagram